What potential investment products could be created around this index and how might they impact market liquidity for private versus public equities?
Potential investment products
Because the ModernâŻMarketâŻ100 is the first index that holds both listed and privateâcompany constituents, it can be licensed for a family ofâŻâdualâexposureâ vehicles:
Product type | How it is structured | Typical investor | Liquidity profile |
---|---|---|---|
ETF/ETN that replicates the index by buying the public stocks outright and holding the privateâstock exposure through a portfolio of PitchBookâregistered privateâfund holdings (e.g., a âcashâsettledâ privateâequity basket). | Passive, lowâcost, continuous pricing via NAV. | Retail & DIY investors, wealthâmanagement platforms. | High on the public side; cashâsettled private component provides daily pricing, modestly increasing daily turnover in the privateâequity market. |
Mutualâfund or UCITS âmodernâmarketâ class that invests directly in the privateâcompany pool via a registered limitedâpartner (LP) or specialâpurpose vehicle (SPV) and holds the public leg as ordinary equities. | Active or indexâtracked; may include a 10â15âŻ% privateâequity allocation that is reâbalanced quarterly. | Institutional, pension, sovereignâwealth funds. | Quarterly rebalancing creates periodic âwindowsâ of privateâequity issuance/redemption, modestly softening the traditionally episodic privateâcapital flow. |
Separately Managed Account (SMA) or âHybridâ Fund that offers a bespoke version of the index for highânetâworth clients, letting them allocate privateâmarket exposure through a subscription line to a privateâEquityâfund GP while keeping the public side in a traditional stockâbrokerage account. | Tailored, with custom cashâreserve and lockâup terms. | UltraâHNW, family offices. | Privateâmarket exposure is still illiquid, but the public side can be traded continuously, improving the overall portfolioâs dayâtoâday liquidity. |
Derivative contracts (futures, swaps, variance swaps) on the index. | Cashâsettled based on the daily NAV of the combined public/private pool. | Hedgeâfunds, macroâtraders, corporate treasuries. | Provide a tradable âpriceâ for the privateâequity component, effectively turning a historically illiquid asset into a dailyâpriced instrument and allowing hedging or speculation without any physical privateâequity purchases. |
Liquidity impact
- Public equities: Adding a privateâequity component to an ETF or fund will not materially affect the underlying publicâmarket turnover; the indexâs public side remains already highly liquid, and the productâs daily creation/redemption mechanism (ETF) or intraâday NAV updates (ETN) will keep it so.
- Private equities: The novelty is the âcashâsettledâ exposure that prices the private side every day. By offering a transparent daily NAV, the index creates a priceâdiscovery mechanism for privateâmarket valuations that previously existed only in quarterly or annual fund valuations. This will encourage more frequent capital flowsâe.g., quarterly fund managers may see a smoother redemption schedule because investors can offset privateâexposure through the liquid public side or via futures. Consequently, the overall privateâmarket liquidity could improve modestly, narrowing the gap between privateâequity transaction costs and publicâequity spreads.
Trading implications
- Shortâ/longâbias opportunities â The indexâs hybrid nature allows a trader to go long the public leg while shorting the private exposure via futures or swaps, essentially betting on a widening or compression of the publicâprivate return spread. Monitor the âprivateâequity premiumâ (historically ~2â5âŻ% per year). A sudden compression (e.g., after a rateâcut cycle) may signal a relative overâvaluation of public stocks versus private assetsâgood for a privateâleg long, publicâleg short trade.
- Liquidity premium capture â Futures on the index will price the combined liquidity premium. A higherâŻcontango (futures > spot) suggests market participants value the private side more than current NAV, indicating a potential carryâtrade: sell the future, buy the index, and earn the spread as privateâmarket valuations catch up.
- Riskâmanagement â Because the private portion is still subject to valuation lag and âlockâupâ risk, any derivative exposure should be hedged with a tighterâspread publicâequity hedge (e.g., a highâbeta ETF) to avoid excess tail risk. Use the indexâs historical volatility (â10â12âŻ% annualized) as a basis for position sizing, and employ stopâlosses near the 1âmonth rollingâbeta breakpoints (â1.5âŻĂâŻaverage volatility) to protect against sudden privateâmarket shock events (e.g., fundâclosure news).
In short, the ModernâŻMarketâŻ100 unlocks a new class of âpublicâprivate blendedâ productsâETFs, mutual funds, SMAs and cashâsettled derivativesâthat will bring daily pricing and hedging tools to privateâequity exposure, modestly improving privateâmarket liquidity while leaving publicâequity liquidity essentially unchanged. Traders can exploit the emerging publicâprivate spread, capture the liquidity premium via futures or swaps, and hedge the residual illiquidity risk with highâbeta public instruments.