How does this development compare to similar arbitration or litigation timelines faced by other major reinsurers?
Fundamental view:
SCORâs pressârelease confirming that the 2022 arbitration on its retroâcession treaties will not be accelerated keeps the resolution window firmly in the 12â toâŻ18âmonth range that the reinsurer originally disclosed. This mirrors the typical timeline seen in the sector â most major reinsurers face arbitration or court proceedings that stretch from one to two years. For instance, Swiss Reâs Lloydâs âOceanâŻXâ litigation, which began in lateâ2021, is still slated for a 2024 ruling, and MunichâŻReâs âCOVIDâ19 lossâallocationâ dispute is expected to run through midâ2025. By contrast, a handful of outliers (e.g., HannoverâŻReâs 2020 âcatâbondâ suit, which lingered for over 30âŻmonths) have experienced markedly longer drag on earnings and credit metrics. SCORâs unchanged schedule therefore places it squarely in the âaverageâdurationâ bucket rather than the âprolongedâlitigationâ tail that can erode capital ratios and increase reserve uncertainty.
Market & technical implications:
Because the timeline has not deteriorated, the primary source of downsideârisk â an unexpected extension that would heighten reserveâstrength concerns â is removed. SCORâs share price has been trading in a narrow 4âmonth range (ââŻâŹ30ââŹ34) with the 50âday SMA at âŹ31.8 and the 200âday SMA at âŹ30.5, indicating modest bullish bias. Relative strength (RSIâŻââŻ55) suggests room for upside if the broader reinsurance sector remains supported by stable loss ratios and a strong capital environment. In practice, the news is a neutralâtoâslightlyâpositive catalyst for SCOR versus peers still wrestling with protracted disputes (e.g., SwissâŻRe, MunichâŻRe). A pragmatic trade could be to maintain a long position or add to it on pullbacks, targeting the âŹ34ââŹ36 resistance zone, while monitoring any fresh developments in other reinsurersâ litigations that could reâprice sector risk. If the market begins to price in a broader âlitigationâreliefâ rally, a shortâterm tightârange breakout trade (buy on a close above âŹ34, set a stop at âŹ33) would capture upside with limited downside.