Are there any notable divergences between the STAX and actual trading volume or price action in the last four weeks?
Short answer:âŻBased on the information provided in the BusinessâŻWire release, there isnât enough data to identify any concrete divergences between the Schwab Trading Activity Index⢠(STAX) and actual marketâwide trading volume or price action for the fourâweek period endingâŻJulyâŻ25âŻ2025.
Why we canât assess a divergence from the news alone
What we have from the news | What is missing to assess divergence |
---|---|
STAX reading: The index rose to 41.79 in July from 40.66 in June (a modest uptick). | Actual marketâwide trading volume (e.g., total shares traded on the NYSE/NASDAQ, or Schwabâspecific trade counts) for the same fourâweek period. |
Qualitative description: The index âranks lowâ (the excerpt cuts off before the full description, but it implies the reading is still in a lowâoptimism zone). | Priceâaction data: S&PâŻ500, Nasdaq Composite, or sectorâlevel price movements, as well as any significant rallies or declines that occurred during the period. |
Contextual note: STAX is âthe only index of its kindâ and reflects behavior (positioning) rather than pure volume or price. | Comparative benchmark: How does the STAX trend compare with other sentiment or activity indices (e.g., VIX, AAII sentiment, retailâflow data). |
Timeframe: Fourâweek period ending JulyâŻ25âŻ2025 (covering roughly JulyâŻ1âJulyâŻ25). | Granular timeline: Weekâbyâweek breakdown to see if any spikes/dips in STAX align with spikes in volume or price moves. |
Because the press release does not include any of the missing pieces (tradingâvolume numbers, price charts, or a sideâbyâside comparison of the STAX versus marketâwide volume/price), we cannot determine whether the modest rise in STAX was accompanied by:
- Higher or lower trading volume than the prior month;
- Price movements that either corroborated the âcautious optimismâ (e.g., an upâtrend in equities) or diverged (e.g., a flat or declining market despite a higher STAX).
What would be required to answer the question definitively
- Aggregate volume data (e.g., total shares traded on U.S. exchanges or Schwabâs own transaction counts) for each of the four weeks ending JulyâŻ25âŻ2025.
- Priceâaction data (closing price, daily range, and any notable intraday moves) for the major indices (S&PâŻ500, Nasdaq, Dow Jones) and/or the mostâtraded securities in the Schwab client universe during that period.
- A timeline matching the STAXâderived weekly scores (e.g., weekâ1âŻ=âŻJulyâŻ1â7, weekâ2âŻ=âŻJulyâŻ8â14, etc.) so the analyst can plot STAX versus the two marketâwide variables and visually spot divergences.
- Statistical comparison (correlation or regression) to quantify any misâalignment between the behavioral index and actual market activity.
Practical next steps
- Dataâpull: Pull the daily and weekly aggregate tradeâvolume data from the Schwab internal reporting system (or from an external source such as Bloomberg/FactSet) for the same fourâweek period.
- Priceâchart: Pull the price series for the relevant benchmark indices (S&PâŻ500, Nasdaq, RussellâŻ2000) and a basket of the mostâtraded stocks in the Schwab client base.
- Overlay analysis: Plot the STAX score (weekly) against the volume series and the priceâtrend line to see whether the STAX rise (41.79 â up from 40.66) aligns with a rise in volume and price appreciation, or whether it diverges (e.g., STAX up but volume down, or price flat despite higher STAX).
- Interpretation: If the STAX is rising while both volume and price are stagnant or declining, that would be a notable divergence suggesting that retail investors are becoming slightly more optimistic but not yet translating that sentiment into actual trades or marketâmoving moves. Conversely, if volume and price are both climbing in step with the STAX, the index would be confirming the marketâwide activity.
Bottom line: The news snippet tells us only that the STAX rose modestly in July. Without additional volume and price data for the same period, we cannot identify any notable divergence between the STAX and actual trading volume or price action. To answer the question with confidence, you would need to pull and compare the actual marketâwide volume and price data for the same fourâweek period. If you have that data, feel free to share it and I can run the comparative analysis for you.