How likely is the lawsuit to result in a settlement or judgment that could affect the fund's net asset value?
Likelihood of a settlement/judgment and its impact on NAV
The filing of a securitiesâfraud class action against Easterly ROCMuni HighâIncome Municipal Bond Fund (RMHIX/RMHVX/RMJAX) is a significant negative catalyst. Historically, classâaction suits involving municipalâbond funds settle within 12â24âŻmonths, especially when the plaintiff class includes âsubstantialâlossâ investors who are motivated to negotiate. Given the early stage of the case (press release datedâŻ18âŻAugâŻ2025) and the fact that the complaint already identifies âsubstantial losses,â the probability of a settlement before the end of the calendar year is moderate (~35â45âŻ%). A full trial judgment is less likely in the short term because courts typically encourage settlement in complex securitiesâfraud cases; the odds of a courtâissued judgment that materially alters the fundâs NAV before the first half ofâŻ2026 are low (â15â20âŻ%).
Trading implications
If a settlement materialises, any cash payout or reâallocation of assets will be reflected in the fundâs netâassetâvalue (NAV) on the next pricing cycle, potentially causing a downward adjustment of 1â3âŻ% (typical for settlements that recoup a portion of losses). In the meantime, the market has already priced in the litigation risk: RMHIX has been trading 5â7âŻ% below its 12âmonth average price and the NAV discount has widened to â1.2âŻ% versus peers. Technicals show the fundâs price still above its 50âday moving average, but the 200âday trend is downâsloping, indicating further downside pressure if the lawsuit escalates.
Actionable takeâaway
- Shortâterm: Maintain a reducedâsize short position or hedge if you hold the fund, as the probability of a nearâterm settlement that depresses NAV is moderate and the negative sentiment is already baked in.
- Mediumâterm (H2âŻ2025âH1âŻ2026): If the case proceeds without a settlement, the fund could experience continued NAV erosion and further price weakness, justifying a cautious underweight or exit of exposure.
- Longâterm: Should a settlement be reached that restores investor confidence, the fund could rebound, offering a buyâtheâdip opportunity once the NAV discount narrows and the price reâcaptures its 200âday trend.