CSL

What are the tax implications for shareholders receiving the increased dividend, especially for those in high-tax brackets?

Created August 07, 2025 at 08:29 PM

Tax implications of the increased dividend ( $1.10  per share / $4.40  annualized) for shareholders – especially those in high‑tax brackets

1. How the dividend is taxed in the United States

Type of dividend	What the IRS looks at	Federal tax rate for 2025*
Qualified dividend	Paid by a U.S. corporation (Carlisle Companies Inc.) to a U.S. shareholder who has held the stock for the required “qualified‑holding period” (generally > 60 days for common stock).	15 % for taxpayers in the 10 %–12 % brackets, 20 % for those in the 37 % bracket (the top ordinary‑income bracket).
Non‑qualified (ordinary) dividend	Any dividend that does not meet the qualified‑dividend requirements (e.g., the holding‑period rule is broken, the stock is a “DRIP” that fails the test, or the payer is a foreign corporation that does not qualify).	Taxed at the shareholder’s ordinary marginal income tax rate (up to 37 % in 2025).

*2025 federal tax brackets (married filing jointly) – the highest bracket is 37 % for taxable income > $693,750.

For single filers the 37 % bracket starts at $578,125.

2. What the increase means for a high‑tax‑bracket investor

Higher taxable cash flow – The dividend per share rises from $1.00 to $1.10, a 10 % increase.
- If you own 10,000 shares, the annual dividend goes from $40,000 to $44,000 – an extra $4,000 of taxable income in 2025.
Federal tax bill rises proportionally –
- Qualified dividend: 20 % (top bracket) × $4,000 extra = $800 extra tax.
- Non‑qualified dividend: ordinary marginal rate (e.g., 37 %) × $4,000 = $1,480 extra tax.
- The exact amount depends on whether the dividend qualifies (see §3 below).
Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) – High‑income taxpayers (modified adjusted gross income > $200,000 for MFJ, $250,000 for single) pay an additional 3.8 % on net investment income, which includes qualified dividends.
- On the $4,000 increase, NIIT adds $152 (3.8 % × $4,000) if you’re above the NIIT threshold.
State and local taxes – Most states tax dividend income as ordinary income. Rates vary (e.g., California 13.3 %, New York 8.82 %). The increase will be added to your state taxable income as well.

3. Determining whether the dividend is qualified (and thus taxed at the lower 15 %/20 % rate)

Requirement	What you must satisfy for the $1.10 dividend to be qualified
Holding period	You must have held the shares for more than 60 days during the 121‑day period that begins 60 days before the dividend’s ex‑date. If you bought the shares within the 60‑day window, the dividend is non‑qualified.
Payer	Carlisle Companies is a U.S. corporation, so it meets the “U.S. payer” test.
Domestic corporation	The company is a domestic corporation, so the “qualified‑foreign‑payer” test is automatically satisfied.
Special corporate classifications	Not applicable – Carlisle is not a REIT, a BDC, or a foreign‑entity that would disqualify the dividend.

Bottom line:

- If you have held the shares > 60 days, the $1.10 dividend is qualified and taxed at the 15 % or 20 % rate (depending on your bracket).

- If you bought the shares within the 60‑day window, the dividend is non‑qualified and taxed at your ordinary marginal rate (up to 37 %).

4. Practical tax‑planning tips for high‑tax‑bracket shareholders

Strategy	How it helps
Check the holding‑period rule	Make sure you have owned the shares for > 60 days before the ex‑date to keep the dividend qualified.
Use tax‑advantaged accounts	Hold the shares in an IRA, Roth IRA, or 401(k) – the dividend is tax‑free (Roth) or tax‑deferred (traditional).
Consider a dividend‑reinvestment plan (DRIP)	If you reinvest the dividend, the additional shares are treated the same as any other purchase; the holding‑period rule still applies to the original shares.
Harvest tax losses	If you have other securities with unrealized losses, you can offset the dividend income with capital‑loss deductions.
Allocate to a lower‑state‑tax jurisdiction	If you have the flexibility to move residence, consider states with no or low dividend tax (e.g., Florida, Tennessee).
Plan for the NIIT	If you are near the $200k/$250k NIIT threshold, the extra dividend may push you over the limit. You can mitigate NIIT by: • Contributing to a Roth IRA (income‑tax‑free), • Using qualified charitable distributions from an IRA, or • Bunching deductions in the same year.
Review your overall portfolio	The dividend increase is modest (10 %). If the cash flow is significant relative to your total income, consider whether you want to increase cash holdings (to meet tax‑payment needs) or use a portion for tax‑efficient investments (e.g., municipal bonds, which are generally exempt from federal tax).

5. Bottom‑line summary for a high‑tax‑bracket investor

Impact	Explanation
Higher cash dividend	$4,000 extra per 10,000 shares in 2025.
Potential extra federal tax	$800 (qualified, 20 % bracket) or $1,480 (non‑qualified, 37 % bracket).
Additional NIIT	$152 if you’re already subject to the 3.8 % Net Investment Income Tax.
State tax	Varies; add the extra dividend to your state taxable income.
Key to limiting tax	Keep the shares for > 60 days to retain qualified‑dividend status; consider holding the stock in tax‑advantaged accounts or offsetting with losses.

6. Disclaimer

The above calculations use 2025 federal tax rates and assume the dividend qualifies for the lower “qualified‑dividend” rate.
State tax rates differ; you should consult your state’s tax authority for the exact impact.
The Net Investment Income Tax applies only if your modified AGI exceeds the applicable thresholds.
Individual circumstances (e.g., other investment income, deductions, credits, alternative minimum tax) can change the final tax liability.

Recommendation:

Speak with a qualified tax professional (CPA, tax attorney, or financial‑planner) to model the exact impact of the increased dividend on your personal tax situation, especially if you are near the high‑income thresholds for the NIIT or state tax brackets.