What is the likely timeline for resolution of the lawsuit (e.g., settlement, dismissal, trial)?
Answer
The press release you quoted does not give a specific schedule for the CapricorâŻTherapeutics (NASDAQ:âŻCAPR) securitiesâfraud class action, so we have to rely on how such cases normally progress in the U.S. federal courts. Below is a stepâbyâstep outline of the typical timeline for a securitiesâfraud class action, together with the range of timeâframes you can realistically expect for each stage.
1. Complaint Filing â Initial Pleadings (0â2âŻmonths)
- What happens: The plaintiff (or the classârepresentative) files the complaint and the defendants (Capricor and its affiliates) receive a summons.
- Typical duration: The filing itself is immediate; the court usually issues a docket entry within a few days. The defendants then have 30âŻdays (sometimes extended to 45âŻdays) to file an answer or a motion to dismiss.
2. Early Motions & Preliminary Disclosures (1â3âŻmonths)
- What happens: The defendant may move to dismiss the case on legal grounds (e.g., lack of standing, failure to allege fraud). The plaintiff may file a âmotion for leave to amendâ if the complaint needs more detail.
- Typical duration: Courts often rule on a motion to dismiss within 45â60âŻdays after the motion is filed. If the motion is denied, the case proceeds to the next stage.
3. ClassâCertification Process (3â9âŻmonths)
- What happens: The plaintiff must prove that the case meets the RuleâŻ23 requirements (numerosity, commonality, typicality, adequacy of representation, etc.). This is usually done via a âRuleâŻ23(a)â motion, followed by a RuleâŻ23(b)(1) or (b)(2) certification hearing.
- Typical duration:
- RuleâŻ23(a) certification â 2â4âŻmonths from filing to courtâs decision.
- RuleâŻ23(b) certification â if the plaintiff seeks a âsubstantialâlikelihoodâ settlement, the court may take an additional 3â5âŻmonths to evaluate the adequacy of the settlement plan and the fairness hearing.
- RuleâŻ23(a) certification â 2â4âŻmonths from filing to courtâs decision.
4. Discovery (6â12âŻmonths total)
- What happens: Both sides exchange documents, take depositions of key executives, and request interrogatories. In securitiesâfraud cases, discovery often focuses on internal communications, research reports, and trading data.
- Typical duration: 6â12âŻmonths is common, though the parties can agree to a shorter schedule if the case is relatively straightforward. Courts may set âdiscovery cutâoffsâ to keep the case moving toward resolution.
5. Settlement Negotiations (2â12âŻmonths)
- What happens: After discovery, the parties usually have a clearer picture of the strengths and weaknesses of the case, which opens the door to settlement talks.
- Typical duration:
- Early settlement â if the evidence of fraud is strong, a settlement can be reached within 2â4âŻmonths after discovery ends.
- Prolonged negotiations â if the parties are at odds, negotiations can stretch 8â12âŻmonths (or longer) and may involve mediation or a âcourtâappointed neutralâ.
- Early settlement â if the evidence of fraud is strong, a settlement can be reached within 2â4âŻmonths after discovery ends.
6. PreâTrial Motions & Trial Preparation (2â4âŻmonths)
- What happens: Either side may file motions for summary judgment, motions to exclude evidence, or motions for a âbifurcatedâ trial (i.e., liability first, damages second).
- Typical duration: Courts usually rule on these motions within 30â60âŻdays after briefing. If the case survives these motions, the parties will set a trial date.
7. Trial (1â3âŻmonths)
- What happens: Securitiesâfraud class actions are benchâtrials (i.e., decided by a judge) in most districts, though a jury trial is possible if requested.
- Typical duration:
- Bench trial â often 2â4âŻweeks of testimony and deliberation.
- Jury trial â can extend to 6â8âŻweeks or longer, depending on the number of witnesses and the complexity of the financial evidence.
- Bench trial â often 2â4âŻweeks of testimony and deliberation.
8. PostâTrial Motions & Appeal (3â12âŻmonths)
- What happens: The losing side may file a âmotion for a new trial,â a âmotion for judgment as a matter of law,â or an appeal of the judgment.
- Typical duration:
- Postâtrial motions â usually decided within 30âŻdays.
- Appeal â a districtâcourt decision can be appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals; the appellate process typically takes 6â12âŻmonths (or longer if the appellate courtâs docket is heavy).
- Postâtrial motions â usually decided within 30âŻdays.
Putting It All Together â A âRuleâofâThumbâ Timeline for the CAPR Case
Phase | Approx. Timeframe |
---|---|
Complaint & Answer | 0â2âŻmonths |
Early Motions | 1â3âŻmonths |
ClassâCertification | 3â9âŻmonths |
Discovery | 6â12âŻmonths (overlapping with classâcert) |
Settlement Negotiations | 2â12âŻmonths (often 4â6âŻmonths after discovery) |
PreâTrial Motions | 2â4âŻmonths |
Trial | 1â3âŻmonths |
PostâTrial/Appeal | 3â12âŻmonths |
Total expected duration: 12âŻtoâŻ36âŻmonths (roughly 1âŻtoâŻ3âŻyears) from filing to final resolution, assuming the case proceeds without extraordinary delays.
Factors That Can Accelerate or Extend the Timeline
Factor | How It Affects Timing |
---|---|
Strength of the alleged fraud | A clear, strong case often leads to a quicker settlement (12â18âŻmonths total). A borderline case may linger in discovery and motions (up to 3âŻyears). |
Number of class members | Very large classes (thousands of investors) can prolong classâcertification and settlementâplan hearings. |
Courtâs docket | Some districts (e.g., Southern District of New York) have heavy caseloads, which can add 2â4âŻmonths to each motion. |
Defendantâs willingness to settle | If Capricor opts for a âquickâcloseâ settlement, the timeline could compress to 12â15âŻmonths. |
Regulatory involvement | If the SEC or other regulators file parallel actions, coordination can add 6â12âŻmonths. |
Complexity of the financial data | Complex valuation models or âfairâvalueâ calculations can stretch discovery and expertâwitness phases. |
What This Means for Investors Right Now
Contact the Firm Promptly â The KirbyâŻMcInerney LLP notice urges investors to email [email protected] or use the provided contact form. Early contact helps you:
- Preserve your right to optâin to the class (if/when itâs certified).
- Receive updates on key dates (e.g., certification hearings, settlementâoffer windows).
- Preserve your right to optâin to the class (if/when itâs certified).
Expect Updates at the âMilestoneâ Points â Most classâaction counsel will send a brief notice when:
- The classâcertification is granted (or denied).
- The discovery cutâoff is set.
- Settlementâoffer periods open.
- The classâcertification is granted (or denied).
Plan for a 12âMonth Minimum âActiveâ Period â Even if the case settles quickly, youâll likely be involved in at least the first year (filing, answer, classâcert, discovery).
Stay Alert for âSettlementâOfferâ Deadlines â If a settlement is reached, the court will issue a ânotice of settlementâ that includes a âclaimsâsubmission deadline.â Those deadlines are often 30â45âŻdays after the notice is posted, so youâll need to act promptly to receive any potential payout.
Bottom Line
- No explicit timeline is disclosed in the press release.
- Based on typical securitiesâfraud class actions, you can expect a **12âtoâ36âŻmonth window from filing to final resolution** (settlement, dismissal, or trial).
- The fastest realistic outcomeâa settlement reached shortly after discoveryâcould be about 12â15âŻmonths.
- If the case proceeds to trial and possibly appeal, the timeline can stretch to 2â3âŻyears (or longer if there are procedural complexities).
Action for you: Reach out to KirbyâŻMcInerney LLP now (as the notice urges) to register your interest, receive caseâspecific updates, and ensure youâre positioned to claim any potential settlement benefits whenâif and whenâthose milestones are reached.